This first one didn't work out completely right. Although it calls for a 1cm gauge for the long picots, I found them too short to be able to get the pointy shape as per the photo on the pattern. It meant I had to pull on them a bit too much thereby distorting the shape of the rings slightly. I may re-do this one with a longer picot gauge.
This second one I really like though I'm not happy with the colours I chose. I think it definitely calls for being re-done in different colours as it's very pretty and I like how the second round overlaps the first. Also, though not a regular FSBS tatter, in this case, I think it is well worth it but I only decided to do so on the second round. So there, two reasons why I will need to re-tat this motif as well.